NA Hee-Ja*
Department of Dental Hygiene, Honam University, Gwangju Metropolitan City, Korea
*Corresponding Author: Na Hee-Ja, Department of Dental Hygiene, Honam University, Gwangju Metropolitan City, Korea, Phone: 821026388820, E-mail: [email protected]
Received Date: September 27, 2024
Published Date: October 30, 2024
Citation: Hee-Ja NA. (2024). Analysis of Dental Hygiene Curriculum in Korea and the United States. Mathews J Dentistry. 8(3):53.
Copyrights: Hee-Ja NA. © (2024).
ABSTRACT
Objectives: This study aims to develop dental hygienist education and basic studies by deriving influential subjects through comparative analysis of dental hygiene curriculum in Korea and the United States. Methods: This study was conducted from March to May 2024 to derive influential topics by comparing and analyzing the curriculum of dental hygienists in the United States and Korea. The research method used the curriculum and existing data posted on the websites of universities in the United States and Korea. The contents of the dental hygienist curriculum were analyzed through the website of the U.S. university, and the contents of the dental hygienist curriculum were analyzed through the domestic university website. The basic fields of dental hygienist education in the United States and Korea were compared, and other subjects were opened focusing on the contents of the three-year and four-year curriculum. The literature review was conducted on 13 universities in the United States and 47 universities in the four-year system, and the curriculum of 59 universities and 25 universities in the three-year and 25 universities in 84 universities in Korea was investigated. In addition, among the basic subjects, the most opened universities were investigated, and the universities including similar names of basic subjects opened in Korea were investigated. Results: Dental hygienists say that Korean dental hygienists supervise oral health education, preventive dental treatment, medical cooperation, and management support and contribute to the improvement of oral health, but clinical dental hygiene is not standardized, so each school is composed of different subjects and educational goals. The dental hygiene department curriculum is conducted around gaining practical experience in the dental clinical field, and students conduct technical training on actual patients. Health center practice is also underway. The dental hygiene department curriculum is an important process to acquire the necessary competencies and expertise as a dental hygienist. Conclusions: The U.S. dental hygiene curriculum included more subjects representing a successful career in dental hygiene. To improve Korean students' clinical practice skills, the evaluation method and evaluation items need to be improved in the clinical dentistry curriculum in Korea
Keywords: Dental Hygienists, Investigation and Analysis, University, Oral Health Education, Oral Pathology, Dental Hygienist, Dental Hygiene Curriculum, Integrated Curriculum.
INTRODUCTION
The Korean Dental Hygiene Curriculum has been continuously developed along with the reorganization of the interdisciplinary system in the Department of Dental Hygiene (Dental Hygiene). From the opening of a professional bachelor's course in 1977, the extension of the education period from two years to three years in 1994, and the opening of a four-year bachelor's degree course in 2002, to today's master's and doctoral courses, the dental hygiene curriculum has developed from the role of dental hygienists based on problem-solving ability in fragmentary knowledge and technical education centered on dental medicine [1-3]. As the education period was extended, the number of subjects increased, which led to the expansion of the work of dental hygienists and changes in national tests, and curriculum research was conducted in response to this [4,5]. In particular, with the opening of the bachelor's degree course, curriculum research was conducted centering on foreign cases such as the United States and Canada, where the dental hygiene academic system was already established [6,7], and various theories for the development of the dental hygiene curriculum were applied and implemented as research for standardization of the curriculum and the dental hygiene academic system suitable for the situation in Korea [8,9] were conducted. As a result, as the education of the dental hygiene work process is carried out, the area is expanding from simple work to comprehensive work [10]. The curriculum should be reflected in the changes of the times and society, and Kohn [11] suggested the influence of the community on the decision of the curriculum [12]. The Korean government is demanding the National Qualifications Framework (NQF) and the National Competency Standards (NCS) as the curriculum policy of junior colleges. The NQF aims to implement a competency-based society in the labor market by reorganizing and interconnecting school education, vocational training, lifelong learning system, and qualification system based on the NCS (National Competency Standards) to link education and employment. NCS represents the job competence required for a company to perform, and systematically analyzes and presents the job demand of industrial sites to link work, education, training, and qualifications and standardize job competency required for all jobs at the national level [13,14].
The Korean Dental Hygiene Curriculum is a curriculum for acquiring knowledge and skills necessary as a dental hygienist. This curriculum aims to prepare dental hygienists to play an important role in dental treatment. The Korean Dental Hygiene Curriculum is provided by universities or junior colleges and generally lasts for three or four years. The curriculum consists of theoretical classes and practices and is designed to help students acquire the skills and knowledge necessary for dental treatment. The theory class deals with a variety of dental-related topics such as dental hygiene, oral anatomy, oral physiology, oral microbiology, prevention dentistry, oral health education, dental materials, and dental radiography. In addition, students learn laws, ethics, and communication skills necessary as a dental hygienist. The practice focuses on gaining direct experience in the field of dental treatment. Students treat patients at dental hospitals and practice the skills and procedures necessary as dental hygienists. Students practice under the supervision of an instructor in an actual dental environment, and practice dental prevention treatment, dental scaling, dental radiography, and oral health education.
Through this, students can improve their understanding and practical skills in the actual dental treatment environment. The Korean Dental Hygiene Curriculum is an important course to acquire the necessary competencies and expertise as a dental hygienist. Through this curriculum, students can contribute to improving patients' oral health by acquiring a deep understanding and skills in dental treatment. This curriculum helps build a career as a dental hygienist and provides employment opportunities in various fields such as dental hospitals, dental clinics, health centers, schools, and research institutes. In addition, dental hygienists can contribute to the improvement of oral health in the community by participating in oral health education and preventive activities. The Korean Dental Hygiene Curriculum is an essential course to acquire expertise and competence as a dental hygienist, and students can acquire knowledge and skills in dental treatment and contribute to improving the oral health of patients [15].
Since its establishment in 1923, the American Dental Hygienists' Association (ADHA) has supported more than 140,000 dental hygienists. The main goal of ADHA is to promote cooperation and communication between dental hygienists and patients. Through this, it is contributing to maintaining oral health and improving the full-body health of the people. Dental hygienists work in a variety of fields and perform a variety of tasks, including education, clinical, research, administration, and treatment. In the United States, the dental hygienist education system consists of junior college, undergraduate, and graduate programs. As of 2002, there are about 250 dental hygienists' education programs in the United States, of which 70 percent are vocational college programs and the remaining 30 percent are undergraduate programs. Undergraduate programs are available in two forms, one is to obtain a bachelor's degree (BS) in dental hygienists, and the other is to obtain a science (AS) degree in dental hygienists. Through these educational programs, dental hygienists acquire specialized knowledge and skills and contribute to maintaining the oral health of patients [16].
The Dental Hygiene Curriculum is a curriculum for acquiring the necessary skills and knowledge as a dental hygienist. In this curriculum, students learn a variety of topics and skills to build a successful career in dental hygiene. American Dental Hygiene Curriculum is offered at a university or junior college and typically includes a two-year, three-year, or four-year degree program. A two-year, three-year program can acquire a quasi-bachelor's degree, and a four-year program can acquire a bachelor's degree. The curriculum consists of theoretical classes and clinical practice, and students can gain hands-on experience to improve their practical skills in the field of dental hygiene.
The purpose of this research committee is to compare and analyze the dental hygiene curriculum in Korea and the United States, derive courses that have clinical impact, and use them as data for developing dental hygienists and basic studies in the future. In other words, we would like to provide basic data that can be used to improve the comprehensive dental hygiene process in Korea by incorporating the U.S. clinical dental hygiene curriculum, which is a highly influential subject in clinical practice.
STUDY POPUL ATION AND METHODOLOGY
Participants and the study design
This study was conducted to analyze the curriculum in dental hygiene department educational institutions in the United States and Korea. The method of selecting participating schools in this study was simple and random sampling.
The study was conducted for two months from March to May 2024. The research method used the curriculum posted on the website of each university and the existing data that have already been analyzed to analyze the curriculum of dental hygiene department educational institutions in the United States and Korea. In the case of domestic dental hygiene department educational institutions, a list of domestic universities was prepared, and the curriculum was collected by visiting the website to analyze the curriculum of each university. To prepare a list of American universities and analyze the curriculum of each university, the curriculum of the domestic dental hygiene department was analyzed, and a comparative analysis of the basic fields of the US and Korean dental hygiene department was conducted. 84 universities in Korea investigated the curriculum for dental hygienists, and the curriculum of 59 three-year colleges and 25 four-year colleges was investigated. In 60 US universities, literature was reviewed in 13 departments of dental hygiene and 47 schools of four-year colleges. The universities that were opened, including similar names of basic subjects opened in Korea, were investigated, and the universities of the most selected subjects among each basic subject were also investigated.
Research Tools
Examination of Dental Hygiene Curriculum and Basic Subjects in Korea and the United States
This study was conducted for two months from March to May 2024. This study investigated the curriculum of dental hygienists in 84 universities in Korea, 59 3-year colleges, and 25 4-year colleges. Literature review was conducted on 13 2-year and 3-year schools and 47 4-year schools out of 60 universities in the United States. The curriculum of the Department of Dental Hygiene in Korea and the United States was compared with the basic subjects. The survey on the same names as basic subjects in Korea was conducted on the curriculum disclosed on the website by the department of dental hygiene of each university or even the names of nine basic subjects opened in cooperation with universities.
Status of the opening of the 2, 3, and 4-year Dental Hygiene Department at U.S. universities
Table 1. Current Status of the 3-4-Year Curriculum for the Dental Hygiene in Korea---84 schools
3-year university (Grade/School name) |
4-year university (Grade/School name) |
|
Gangneung Yeongdong University Kyungbuk College Naju College Gwangyang Health Sciences University Gumi University Gimcheon University Daewon University College Daejeon Institute of Scence and Technology Mokpo Science University Busan Women's College Sorabol University Songho University Suseong University Suwon Science College Yeoju Institute of Technology Youngnam Foreign Language College Chunnam Techno University Jeonbuk Science College Jeju Tourism University Jinju health college Cheonam College Chungchong University Pohang university Hallym Polytechnic university Haneso university Hanyeong university |
Catholic Sangji College Advanced course Gangdong University Advanced course Kyungnam College of Information & Technology Advanced course Taegu Science University Advanced course Daegu Health College Advanced course Dongnam Health University Advanced course Busan Health University Advanced course Masan University Advanced course Baekseok Culture University Advanced course Busan Institute of Science and Technology Advanced course Sahmyook Health University Advanced course Suwon Women's University Advanced course Shingu College Advanced course Shinsung University Advanced course Yeungnam University College Advanced course Ulsan College Advanced course Jeonju Kijeon College Advanced course Choonhae College Advanced course Chungbuk Health&Science University Advanced course Hanyang Women's University Advanced course Kyungbok College Advanced course Gwangju Health University Advanced course Daejeon Health University Advanced course Seoyeong University Advanced course Andong Science Advanced course Wonkwang Health Science University Advanced course U1 University Advanced course Vision college of Jeonju Advanced course Hyejeon College Advanced course |
Gachon University Catholic Kwandong University Gangneung Wonju National University Konyang University Kyungdong University Kyungpook National University Kwangju Women's University Namseoul University Dankook University Dongseo University Dong-eui University Baekseok University Sunmoon University Songwon University Silla University shinhan University Yonsei University Youngsan University Eulji University Cheongju University Chodang University Honam University Howon University |
Total College 84 schools |
3-year College 59 schools, Advanced Course 31 schools |
4-year College 25 schools |
Status of the opening of the U.S. Department of Dental Hygiene in the U.S
Table 2. Dental Hygiene Department of the U.S. University of America's 2, 3, 4-year system
2,3-year university (Grade/School name) |
4-year university (Grade/School name) |
-Bergen Community College -Central Community College - Easten Washington university -Louisiana collage -Massachusetts College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences -Medical College of Georgia -Mount Ido College -Oregon Institute of Technology -Pennsylvania Collage of technology -SUNY—Farmingdale -Thomas Edison state Collage -West Liberty State College -
|
-NYU College of Dentistry Department of Dental Hygiene and Dental Assisting -Massachusetts College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences -Fones School Dental Hygiene Curriculum -Armstrong Atlantic State university -Clayton State university -Dahlhaus university -East Tennessee State university -Idaho university -Midwestern State university -Minnesota State University Mankato -Northern Arizona university -Ohio State University Columbus -Old Dominion university -Tennessee state university -Texas Woman’s university - University of Detroit Mercy - University of Hawaii—Manoa - University of Louisiana—Lafayette - University of Louisiana --Monroe - University of Louisville - University of Maine—Augusta - University of Maryland—Baltimore - University of—Eastern Shore - University of—Ann Arbor - University of Minnesota—Twin Cities - University of Missouri—Kansas City - University of New England - University of New Haven - University of New Mexico - University of North Carolina—Chapel Hill - University of Oklahoma - University of Pittsburgh - University of Rhode Island - University of south California - University of Southern Indiana - University of Tennessee - University of Washington - University of Wyoming - University of Pacific -Verginia of Commonwealth University -Weber State University - West Verginia university -Western Kentucky university -Wichita State university -University of Bridgeport -University of British Columbia - University of Colorado –Denver and Health Sciences Center |
2,3-year university (Grade/School name): 13university (Grade/School name) |
4-year university:47 university (Grade/School name) |
Total |
60 university |
Korean and U.S. Dental Hygiene Department Programming and Completion of 3-4 Year Curriculum
Table 3. Korean and U.S. Department of Dental Hygiene in Korea 3~4 years of curriculum organization and completion credits
Sortation |
The number of universities |
General/basic liberal arts |
Major |
Number of subjects |
A total of credits completed |
Republic of Korea |
84 |
14~36 |
100~129 |
50~70 |
120~130 |
the United States |
60 |
31~54 |
50~95 |
19~30 |
87~123 |
Processing statistics
The data collection of this study used references such as prior research, various statistical data, and government publications, as well as Internet searches through the relevant institution's website, such as the American Association of Dental Examiners (AADE), the National Dental Hygiene Certification Board (NDCB), and the ADHA (Australian Dental Hygiene Association), and more specific details were collected through e-mail with related parties. In addition, the curriculum of dental hygiene in Korea and the United States surveyed was compared, and similar names were confirmed for each subject for basic domestic subjects. For statistical processing, the SPSS 24.0 (IBM Corp. Armonk, NY, USA) program was used, and the statistical significance level was P <.05.
THE RESULTS OF THE STUDY
Comprehensive data on Korean dental hygiene department curriculum analysis (3,4 years)
Table 4. Comprehensive data on Korean dental hygiene department curriculum analysis (3,4 years)
Domain |
Subject |
Class |
Credit |
Category |
Basic dental hygiene |
Human anatomy physiology |
1 |
2 |
major selection |
Oral pathology |
1 |
2 |
major selection |
|
Dental pharmacology |
1 |
2 |
major selection |
|
Dental terminology |
1 |
2 |
major selection |
|
Oral Physiology and Practice |
1 |
2 |
major selection |
|
Oral Anatomy and Practice |
1 |
2 |
major selection |
|
Dental morphology and Practice |
1 |
3 |
major required |
|
Oral Microbiology and Practice |
2 |
2 |
major selection |
|
Oral Pathology and Practice |
2 |
2 |
major selection |
|
Oral Histology and Practice |
2 |
2 |
major selection |
|
Dental clinical psychology |
2 |
2 |
major selection |
|
Oral Hygiene |
Public oral health and Practice |
3 |
2 |
major selection |
Oral health pedagogy and Practice |
3 |
3 |
major required |
|
Infection prevention |
1 |
2 |
major selection |
|
Introduction to Dental Hygiene |
1 |
2 |
major selection |
|
Prophylaxis and Practice |
2 |
3 |
major required |
|
Oral Prophylaxis and Practice |
2 |
3 |
major required |
|
Dental Statistics |
3 |
2 |
major selection |
|
Dental Hygiene Seminar |
4 |
1 |
major selection |
|
Dental clinical |
Periodontology |
2 |
2 |
major required |
Conservative Dentistry |
3 |
2 |
major required |
|
Orthodontics |
3 |
2 |
major required |
|
Dental Prosthetics |
3 |
2 |
major required |
|
Oral Surgery |
3 |
2 |
major selection |
|
Pediatric Dentistry |
3 |
2 |
major required |
|
Dental Materials and practice |
3 |
2 |
major selection |
|
Radiology |
3 |
2 |
major required |
|
Radiology and Practice |
3 |
2 |
major required |
|
Dental health insurance |
3 |
2 |
major selection |
|
Dental health insurance practice |
3 |
2 |
major selection |
|
Dental care management |
3 |
2 |
major selection |
|
Dental first aid |
1 |
2 |
major selection |
|
Pre-dental practice |
3 |
2 |
major selection |
|
Suburban clinical practice |
2 |
1 |
major selection |
Korean Dental Hygiene and Liberal Arts (3,4 years)
Table 5. Korean Dental Hygiene and Liberal Arts (3,4 years)
Subject |
Class |
Credit |
Category |
Dental ethics |
3 |
3 |
liberal arts |
Hospital coordinator ology |
3 |
1 |
liberal arts |
Oral diagnostics |
2 |
2 |
liberal arts |
Oral hygiene |
2 |
2 |
liberal arts |
Hospital management and practice |
2 |
2 |
liberal arts |
Dietetics |
2 |
2 |
liberal arts |
Investigation methodology |
3 |
2 |
liberal arts |
Oral Health administration |
3 |
2 |
liberal arts |
Medical laws and regulations |
4 |
2 |
liberal arts |
Understanding college life and major |
1 |
0.5 |
liberal arts |
Competency development |
2 |
0.5 |
liberal arts |
career planning |
3 |
0.5 |
liberal arts |
Thinking and Expression |
3 |
3 |
liberal arts |
Implantology |
3 |
2 |
liberal arts |
Geriatric Oral Rehabilitation |
2 |
2 |
liberal arts |
Clinical Psychology |
2 |
2 |
liberal arts |
Oral health system |
2 |
2 |
liberal arts |
English |
1 |
3 |
liberal arts |
Public Oral Health |
1 |
3 |
liberal arts |
Chemistry/physics select 1 |
1 |
3 |
liberal arts |
Results of a similar name survey of basic Korean subjects
Table 6. Currently using names opened for Oral Anatomy
1 |
Oral anatomy |
30 |
32.96 |
2 |
Orofacial Anatomy, Histology and embryology |
1 |
1.09 |
3 |
Oral Anatomy and Practice |
16 |
17.58 |
4 |
Head and Neck Anatomy |
14 |
15.38 |
5 |
Head and Neck Anatomy and Practice |
12 |
13.18 |
6 |
Head and neck anatomy practice |
1 |
1.09 |
7 |
Anatomy of the Head and Neck |
1 |
1.09 |
8 |
Human anatomy |
8 |
8.79 |
9 |
Dentistry and Oral Anatomy and Physiology |
1 |
1.09 |
10 |
Dental Anatomy, Embryology and Histology |
1 |
1.09 |
11 |
Anatomy and Physiology 1 |
3 |
3.29 |
12 |
Anatomy and Physiology 2 |
3 |
3.29 |
Sum |
91 |
|
1 |
Oral Embryology and Histology |
2 |
2.4 |
2 |
Orofacial Anatomy, Histology and embryology |
1 |
1.2 |
3 |
Oral tissue and embryology |
8 |
9.63 |
4 |
Oral tissue and development |
1 |
1.2 |
5 |
Oral tissue development |
3 |
3.61 |
6 |
Oral tissue embryology |
50 |
60.24 |
7 |
Oral tissue embryology and practice |
3 |
3.61 |
8 |
Advanced oral tissue embryology |
1 |
1.2 |
9 |
Oral histology |
6 |
7.22 |
10 |
Oral histology and practice |
2 |
2.4 |
11 |
Tissue embryology |
3 |
3.61 |
12 |
Histology and Embryology |
1 |
1.2 |
13 |
Dental Anatomy and Histology |
1 |
1.2 |
14 |
Dental Anatomy, Embryology and Histology |
1 |
1.2 |
Sum |
83 |
1 |
Oral pathology |
1 |
1.19 |
2 |
Oral pathology |
68 |
80.95 |
3 |
Oral Pathology and Practice |
4 |
4.76 |
4 |
Advanced oral pathology |
1 |
1.19 |
5 |
Pathology |
4 |
4.76 |
6 |
General and Oral Pathology |
4 |
4.76 |
7 |
Dental hygiene pathology |
2 |
2.38 |
Sum |
84 |
1 |
Oral physiology |
2 |
2.22 |
2 |
Oral physiology |
59 |
65.55 |
3 |
Oral Physiology and Practice |
2 |
2.22 |
4 |
Physiology |
6 |
6.66 |
5 |
Human Anatomy Physiology and Practice |
1 |
1.11 |
6 |
General Anatomy and Physiology 1 |
1 |
1.11 |
7 |
General Anatomy and Physiology 2 |
1 |
1.11 |
8 |
Dentistry and Oral Anatomy and Physiology |
1 |
1.11 |
9 |
Dental Hygiene Physiology |
2 |
2.22 |
10 |
Anatomy physiology |
9 |
10 |
11 |
Anatomy and Physiology 1 |
3 |
3.33 |
12 |
Anatomy and Physiology 2 |
3 |
3.33 |
Sum |
90 |
|
1 |
oral microorganisms |
2 |
2.4 |
2 |
Oral microorganisms and immunity |
1 |
1.2 |
3 |
Oral microbiology and immunology practice |
1 |
1.2 |
4 |
Oral microbiology |
50 |
60.24 |
5 |
Oral Microbiology and Immunology |
8 |
9.63 |
6 |
Oral Microbiology and Practice |
5 |
6.02 |
7 |
Oral Microbiology and Infection Control |
1 |
1.2 |
8 |
Oral physiology and microorganisms |
1 |
1.2 |
9 |
Microbiology and infection control |
1 |
1.2 |
10 |
Microbiology and Immunology |
1 |
1.2 |
11 |
Microbiology and Immunology Lab |
1 |
1.2 |
12 |
Microbiology |
5 |
6.02 |
13 |
Microbiology and Immunology |
1 |
1.2 |
14 |
Medical microbiology |
1 |
1.2 |
15 |
Human Microbiology 1 |
1 |
1.2 |
16 |
Human Microbiology 2 |
1 |
1.2 |
17 |
Dental Hygiene Microbiology |
2 |
2.4 |
Sum |
83 |
|
1 |
Public oral health administration |
1 |
7.14 |
2 |
Public Oral Health Administration |
1 |
7.14 |
3 |
Oral health administration |
6 |
42.85 |
4 |
Oral Health Administration |
5 |
35.71 |
5 |
Dental administration practice |
1 |
7.14 |
Sum |
14 |
1 |
Oral health research and health statistics |
1 |
1.61 |
2 |
Oral health statistics |
2 |
3.22 |
3 |
Oral Health Statistics |
28 |
45.16 |
4 |
Oral health statistics and practice |
5 |
8.06 |
5 |
Oral health statistics and research methodology |
1 |
1.61 |
6 |
Oral health statistics practice |
1 |
1.61 |
7 |
Oral statistics |
1 |
1.61 |
8 |
Health statistics |
10 |
16.12 |
9 |
Health Statistics and Practice |
6 |
9.67 |
10 |
Health Statistics Practice |
1 |
1.61 |
11 |
Advanced health statistics |
1 |
1.61 |
12 |
Dental hygiene research and statistics |
1 |
1.61 |
13 |
Dental hygiene statistics and thesis research |
1 |
1.61 |
14 |
Statistics |
2 |
3.22 |
15 |
Statistics 1 |
1 |
1.61 |
Sum |
62 |
|
1 |
Education Dental Hygiene Community Practice |
1 |
0.83 |
2 |
Education Dental Hygiene |
2 |
1.66 |
3 |
Education Dental Hygiene and Practice |
2 |
1.66 |
4 |
Introduction to Education |
2 |
1.66 |
5 |
Oral health education |
1 |
0.83 |
6 |
Oral health education practice project |
1 |
0.83 |
7 |
Oral health education practice |
5 |
4.16 |
8 |
Oral health education practice capstone design |
2 |
1.66 |
9 |
Oral Health Education |
35 |
29.16 |
10 |
Oral health education and practice |
34 |
28.33 |
11 |
Oral Health Education and Practice II |
10 |
8.33 |
12 |
Oral health education practice |
19 |
15.83 |
13 |
Health education methodology |
2 |
1.66 |
14 |
Health Education |
4 |
3.33 |
Sum |
120 |
|
1 |
Oral medical laws and regulations |
1 |
1.26 |
2 |
Health regulations |
2 |
2.53 |
3 |
Health and medical laws and regulations |
9 |
11.39 |
4 |
Health care laws and regulations |
35 |
44.3 |
5 |
Health care law 2 |
2 |
2.53 |
6 |
Health care laws and ethics |
1 |
1.26 |
7 |
Health care law theory |
1 |
1.26 |
8 |
Health care ethics and laws |
1 |
1.26 |
9 |
Medical related laws and regulations |
21 |
26.58 |
10 |
Medical laws and medical ethics |
1 |
1.26 |
11 |
Medical related laws and regulations practice |
2 |
2.53 |
12 |
Medical regulations |
1 |
1.26 |
13 |
Clinical health care laws and regulations |
1 |
1.26 |
14 |
Dental hygiene ethics and health laws |
1 |
1.26 |
Sum |
79 |
|
Comprehensive data on the analysis of the curriculum of the U.S. Department of Dental Hygiene (3,4 years)
Table 15. Comprehensive data on the analysis of the curriculum of the Department of Dental Hygiene in the United States (3,4 years)
Course Name |
Grade |
Credit |
Major Selection |
|
Biology 1: Cell and Molecular Biology |
1 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
Biology 1 Lab 11 |
1 |
1 |
Major Selection |
|
Chemistry Principal 1 |
1 |
4 |
Major Selection |
|
Introduction to Major 1 |
1 |
1 |
Major Selection |
|
Commentary Writing1 |
1 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
Calculus1 |
1 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
Biology 2: Biology |
1 |
4 |
Major Selection |
|
Biology 2: Biology |
1 |
4 |
Major Selection |
|
Chemical Principles 2 |
1 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
Differential calculus 2 |
1 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
Introduction to Psychology |
1 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
Anatomy and physiology1 |
1 |
4 |
Major Selection |
|
Anatomy and physiology2 |
1 |
4 |
Major Selection |
|
HUM Deployment Elective Course |
1 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
Introduction to Interpersonal Communication for Health Experts |
1 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
organic chemistry |
2 |
4 |
Major Selection |
|
American culture, identity, and public life |
2 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
health psychology |
2 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
Fundamentals of Physics 1 |
2 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
Foundation of Physics Laboratory 1 |
2 |
1 |
Major Selection |
|
Organic Chemistry 2 |
2 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
Laboratory 2 of Organic Chemistry |
2 |
1 |
Major Selection |
|
cultural anthropology |
2 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
medical ethics |
2 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
Fundamentals of Physics 2 |
2 |
4 |
Major Selection |
|
medical microbiology |
2 |
4 |
Major Selection |
|
Statistics |
2 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
biochemistry |
2 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
Nutrition |
2 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
Dental anatomy and histology |
3 |
2 |
Major Selection |
|
head and neck anatomy |
3 |
2 |
Major Selection |
|
Dental Hygiene Treatment Course 1 |
3 |
4 |
Major Selection |
|
a dental hygiene preclinical laboratory |
3 |
2 |
Major Selection |
|
Dental radiology department |
3 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
dental materials |
3 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
Dental Hygiene Treatment Course 2 |
3 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
Clinic 1 |
3 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
periodontology |
3 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
pathology |
3 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
pain management |
3 |
2 |
Major Selection |
|
a pain management lab |
3 |
1 |
Major Selection |
|
Dental Hygiene Treatment Course 3 |
3 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
community oral health |
3 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
An oral health study |
3 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
Clinical Dental Hygiene 2 |
3 |
4 |
Major Selection |
|
Dental Hygiene Treatment Course 4 |
4 |
2 |
Major Selection |
|
Clinical Dental Hygiene 3 |
4 |
4 |
Major Selection |
|
pharmacology |
4 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
Capstone Leadership in Dental Hygiene |
4 |
3 |
Major Selection |
|
Practice and career management |
4 |
2 |
Major Selection |
Arican student dental hygiene education program recognition evaluation (ASDHEP)
Table 16. American student dental hygiene education program recognition evaluation (ASDHEP: Accreditation of Dental Hygiene Education Program in the United States)
Course Name |
Grade |
Credit |
Major Selection |
Anatomy |
2 |
3 |
Major Selection |
physiology |
2 |
3 |
Major Selection |
chemistry |
2 |
3 |
Major Selection |
biochemistry |
1 |
3 |
Major Selection |
Microbiology (Microbiology and Immunology) |
1 |
3 |
Major Selection |
Immunology |
1 |
3 |
Major Selection |
General pathology (General oral pathology) |
2 |
3 |
Major Selection |
Nutrition (Dental Nutrition) |
1 |
3 |
Major Selection |
pharmacology |
1 |
3 |
Major Selection |
the morphology of teeth |
1 |
3 |
Major Selection |
Head and neck and oral anatomy |
2 |
3 |
Major Selection |
Oral development and histology |
2 |
3 |
Major Selection |
oral pathology |
2 |
3 |
Major Selection |
Communication Management |
2 |
3 |
Major Selection |
DISCUSSION
Dental hygiene is a technological science that provides behavioral management, prevention, and oral health care for the prevention and health promotion of oral diseases. For this purpose, the Korean dental hygiene curriculum is being developed focusing on theories and technologies such as oral health education, preventive dental treatment, dental treatment cooperation, and management support [18]. Currently, the Korean dental hygienists work is faithful to its role and acquires theories and skills necessary for performance. However, there is a growing demand for a developmental role in the work of dental hygienists. In the case of the United States, the dental hygiene process is carried out by presenting 'performance required of new dental hygienists' as an educational goal, and the state has established standards for recognizing dental hygiene curriculum and operates detailed majors as an integrated subject [15,19].
As there is a developmental demand for the role of dental hygienists in Korea, it is necessary to develop a curriculum by grasping the work contents and demands of dental hygienists [20]. In addition, when developing the curriculum for dental hygienists, it is important to reflect on the latest knowledge and skills. As there is a developmental demand for the role of dental hygienists, it is necessary to develop a curriculum by grasping the job performance and educational needs of dental hygienists. To this end, it is necessary to analyze the job contents of clinicians and develop a curriculum that can strengthen the capabilities of dental hygienists. In addition, when developing a curriculum, it is necessary to reflect the job performance and educational needs of dental hygienists so that dental hygienists have the necessary competencies in the field. In Korea, the standardization of clinical dentistry has not been made with different subject names and educational goals such as dental pedagogy, comprehensive dental hygiene, and preventive dentistry for each school or school [20].
Integrated clinical dentistry based on dental competency should be standardized through efforts such as implementing a certification system to evaluate the dental hygiene curriculum in line with the demand for the integration of subjects centered on the dental hygiene management process in the Korean curriculum. The dental hygiene community has led quantitative changes over the past few decades. Improving the quality of education and approving it as an international curriculum are considered key tasks that Korean dental hygiene education must solve, and most urgently, it is judged that it is very important to recognize the necessity and share information among educators regarding the standardization of the clinical dental hygiene curriculum (Table 4 & 5).
Bae SM, et al. [21]. As a result of analyzing the curriculum according to dental hygiene competency, it is necessary to further subdivide and define the concept of dental hygiene competency in the future because the dental hygiene competency to be achieved is operated somewhat inefficiently in the fields of basic dental hygiene, dental clinical studies, and clinical dental hygiene. In addition, it was suggested that educational methods such as problem-based learning, case-based learning, project-based learning, and team-based learning need to be developed and applied to the clinical dentistry curriculum, rather than the existing lecture-style education method so that students can think and judge the learning contents of the pre-subject in an integrated manner, such as Clinical Dental Hygiene and Practice III to VI. The clinical dental hygiene practice in Korea is operated by one professor and 22 students as a team and operates 3 to 5 hours per week. Therefore, standardization and guidelines should be presented at the national level for the clinical practice capabilities of dental hygienists in accordance with the domestic situation, and each school needs to present the core competencies and detailed competencies of dental hygienists at the time of graduation and open and operate an integrated clinical dental hygiene course centered on the dental hygiene management process to achieve them.
Clinical dental hygiene education in the United States and Korea aims to provide a variety of subjects with an appropriate process of dental hygiene management. In the United States, theory and practice prepare for tasks to be performed in the actual field after graduation. This includes applying periodontal devices, coping methods in emergency situations, infection control, local anesthesia, prescription and education of self-mouth hygiene products, effective communication skills, dental hygiene management, and data collection to identify subject needs. However, Korea is sometimes not legally recognized for some tasks. In addition to knowledge and skills, the United States emphasizes humanities and social knowledge such as communication, cognition, and psychology. To this end, related knowledge is integrated through methods such as essays, discussions, and presentations, and creative and logical thinking skills are cultivated.
In the United States, clinical dental hygiene practice is conducted in a team of 1 professor and 5 students, with 14 to 21 hours of practice per week. In addition, a customer/patient contact confirmation and internship execution tracking form for each student are completed, reviewed and supplemented with the instructor. Through this, instructors can invest sufficient time to provide individual guidance and feedback to students and improve their clinical competence [22].
To improve the clinical practice capabilities of Korean students, the evaluation method and evaluation items need to be improved in the clinical dentistry curriculum in Korea. Through this, students' clinical skills can be accurately evaluated and improved, and students should acquire expertise as dental hygienists by integrating theories and practices. It is true that there has been a lot of development in the education of dental hygienists in Korea for about 38 years. In particular, the interdisciplinary system changed as the duration of class increased, and junior colleges are conducting a major intensive course and the subjects taken by the national examination dental hygienists are progressively improved to train dental hygienists. In this process, it was classified into basic subjects and clinical subjects, and the distribution of the number of questions by national examination subject also adjusted and developed. However, without the NCS being established, our efforts to standardize basic subjects for each university seem to have been insufficient. As shown in this study, similar names for each basic subject are very diverse, and there are many mixed names centered on the professor's own major, so the identity of a single subject viewed from the perspective of students seems very low. In consideration of the problem of this perspective, I hope that a concise and clear subject that fits the eye level of students who are the parties to education demand will be presented. This is because, looking at the examples of names of each basic subject taken from Table 6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13 & 14, oral facial anatomy, histology and embryology, dental and oral anatomy and physiology, dental anatomy, embryology and histology, oral facial anatomy, histology and embryology, dental anatomy and histology, dental and oral anatomy and physiology, educational dental hygiene community practice, public oral health administration (Table 6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13 & 14).
In addition, just as the dental hygienist curriculum in the United States conducts training for various subjects such as children, adolescents, adults, the elderly, and special patients, it is necessary to strengthen training for various subjects in the Korean curriculum. Through this, students will be able to cope with various situations and demonstrate their ability as experts in clinical practice after graduation. In conclusion, in the clinical dentistry curriculum, the improvement of evaluation methods and evaluation items, and the practice for various subjects should be strengthened to improve students' clinical practice skills, and to equip them with expertise as dental hygienists. Through this, students can fulfill their roles and responsibilities as dental hygienists and contribute to the promotion of national oral health. Tables 15 and 16 suggest that when operating in higher grades such as clinical dentistry and practice III-VI, it is necessary to develop educational methods such as problem-based learning, case-based learning, project-based learning, and team-based learning to replace the existing lecture-style education methods. Through this, it helps to think and judge the learning contents of the prerequisite subject in an integrated manner. Standardization and guidelines should be presented at the national level for the clinical practice competency of dental hygienists in line with the domestic situation. Based on this, each school needs to present the core competencies and detailed competencies of dental hygienists at the time of graduation, and open and operate an integrated clinical dental hygiene course centered on the dental hygiene management process to achieve this. In the case of the United States, the curriculum of dental hygiene and other dentistry is evaluated through a certification system called CODA. This system enables integrated education centered on competency to improve the performance ability of the dental hygiene (academic) curriculum centered on the dental hygiene management process. In Korea, the need for establishing the concept of the dental hygiene management process in the curriculum and for a transition from fragmentary clinical formulas to comprehensive dental hygiene management process services was raised [23].
This study has several limitations. To conduct an in-depth analysis of the U.S. clinical dentistry curriculum, it is difficult to regard it as a sample representing the U.S. clinical dentistry curriculum because only 60 universities where detailed information is available were targeted. The inability to compare and analyze cases of other countries in which the clinical dentistry curriculum is standardized and operated is a limitation of this study, and continuous research is needed for the development of the domestic dental hygiene curriculum and the development of an effective curriculum.
CONCLUSION
As a result of the study, it was confirmed that there were several differences between the Korean dental hygiene curriculum and the US dental hygiene curriculum. For example, the US dental hygiene curriculum included more subjects representing a successful career in dental hygiene. To improve Korean students' clinical practice competency, the clinical dental hygiene curriculum in Korea needs to improve evaluation methods and evaluation items. Through this, students' clinical skills can be accurately evaluated and improved, and students should acquire expertise as dental hygienists by integrating theories and practices.
CLINICAL RELEVANCE
Scientific rationale for the study
The Korean dental hygiene curriculum, strengthening subjects for a successful career, and improving evaluation items play an important role in training dental hygienists, contributing to improving students' clinical capacity and ensuring legal work.
Principal findings
There is a need to improve the evaluation methods and evaluation items of the Korean clinical dental curriculum to improve the clinical practice of Korean students
Practical implications
There is a need to improve the evaluation method and evaluation items of clinical dentistry in Korea. An evaluation method that can substantially improve the clinical competence of students in the school curriculum should be introduced. Through this, students can identify their lack of competencies and find ways to improve them with instructors. In addition, evaluation in the school curriculum should be more specific, diverse and subdivided. Through this, an evaluation of literacy, knowledge, skills, and integrated performance ability in various areas that a dental hygienist must have as a health care professional should be made.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
The author declares that there is no conflict of interest.
AUTHOR CONTRIBUTION
The author approved the final version of this manuscript prior to submission and agreed to be responsible for all aspects of the work ensuring that questions relating to the accuracy or integrity of all parts of the question or task related to accuracy have been properly addressed. KNH, NHJ contributed to design, search and selection, analysis and interpretation, drafted manuscripts, contributed to concepts and design, search and selection, analysis and interpretation, and critically modified manuscripts. The NHJ contributed to the concept, design, analysis and interpretation, and critically modified the manuscript.
DATA AVAILABILITY STATEMENT
Research data are not shared.
REFERENCES